Road trip ratedpacifica_hybrid_ownerOPLongmont, CO
#1
63 posts · joined Nov 20252022 Pacifica Hybrid, 7 seats, two kids
colorado, so snow is not theoretical for me, and the next van is probably an AWD Sienna because the hybrid is front drive and the passes get hairy. doing my homework i hit the thing nobody told me: the 2011 to 2020 AWD Sienna comes on run-flat tires and has no spare at all. the all wheel drive hardware sits where the spare well would be, so toyota deleted the spare and put run-flats on so you can limp to a shop on a flat.
a few problems with that for a family van. run-flats ride stiff and loud, they wear faster, they cost more, and the selection is thin so you are often stuck with whatever the one run-flat the size comes in. and a run-flat that goes flat is not repairable in most shops' policies, so a nail means a new tire, not a 25 dollar plug.
so for the AWD Sienna owners here, what did you actually do. did you keep the run-flats, or switch to regular tires and carry a plug kit and a 12 volt pump, and if you switched, what did you do about having no spare. i would rather learn this from you than from a flat on a pass with the kids in the back.
Daily pickupcarpool_every_dayOshkosh, WI
#2
47 posts · joined Nov 20252014 Odyssey EX-L, 198k, school run
i do not have the Sienna AWD but i will say the part that matters most and people skip. AWD gets you going, winter tires get you stopping and turning, and only one of those keeps you out of the ditch. i run my front drive Odyssey on dedicated snow tires on their own steel wheels and it out drives half the AWD crossovers around here that are on worn all seasons, because they can accelerate and then they cannot stop.
so whatever you decide on the run-flat question, the real answer to "what do you run in snow" is a set of actual winter tires, mounted on their own wheels, swapped on in november. that is the single biggest safety upgrade you can make to any van, AWD or not, and it is cheaper than one fender.
Moderatormod_paula_vLa Crosse, WI
#3
58 posts · joined Nov 20252018 Sienna LE, 112k, carpool and a canoe
my 2018 is a front driver so i dodged the run-flat issue, but i have helped two friends with AWD Siennas and both did the same thing. they switched off the run-flats to regular tires at the first replacement, because the ride and the cost were not worth it, and they bought a compact spare and a small jack that live in a bin in the back. you can get a non run-flat that fits and a plug kit and a 12 volt pump and still come out ahead of a set of run-flats, and you get a quieter van.
the one honest downside of switching: without a run-flat, a flat on the highway means you are stopping to plug it or put the little spare on in the cold, instead of limping to the next exit. with three kids in the back in january that is a real consideration, so some people keep the run-flats for exactly that reason. it is a genuine trade, not a clear win either way.
whatever tire you land on, buy the winter set carpool is talking about. for a van the usual suspects are the Blizzak and the Michelin ice tires, and the makers list the sizes that fit your van on their own sites, for Bridgestone that is bridgestonetire.com.
Carpool regularsienna_xle_newMarietta, GA
#4
12 posts · joined Nov 20252020 Sienna XLE AWD, 7 seats, three kids under 6
this is timely because my 2020 XLE AWD is exactly the van you are describing and i am about to drive it from georgia to ohio for the holidays. mine came on the factory run-flats and they are worn, so i just put a set of dedicated winter tires on their own steel wheels for the trip, and i will run the run-flats the rest of the year until they are done and then switch to regular tires.
for the no spare problem in the meantime i did the cheap thing, a plug kit and a little 12 volt compressor in the bin under the floor, about 40 dollars together. i will report back after the drive whether the AWD and the winter tires were worth it or whether i just scared myself. the no spare thing did bug me, i will be honest, a georgia guy is not used to a van with no spare.
Road trip ratedpacifica_hybrid_ownerOPLongmont, CO
#5
63 posts · joined Nov 20252022 Pacifica Hybrid, 7 seats, two kids
this is the answer i was after, thank you. the consensus i am taking away: the AWD is nice to have but the winter tires are the thing that actually matters, switch off the run-flats at replacement for ride and cost, and carry a plug kit and a 12 volt pump plus maybe a compact spare since the van has none.
sienna_xle_new, please do report back after the ohio drive, because you are running the exact setup i am considering, AWD plus proper winter tires, and i want to know if it felt like money well spent on the passes or just a nice feeling. that is the data point i cannot get from a brochure.
Road trip ratedtiming_belt_v6Salem, OR
#6
82 posts · joined Nov 20252013 Odyssey Touring, 141k, timing belt done at 105k
oregon coast range, so chains and passes are my normal. one thing to add that is easy to forget on an AWD van with winter tires: you can still be required to carry chains over some mountain passes regardless of what tires or drive system you have, and the sign at the bottom of the pass does not care that your van is all wheel drive. keep a set of cable chains that fit your tire size in the van from november on, even if you never put them on, because the fine and the turnaround for not having them is worse than the twenty minutes it takes to practice fitting them in your driveway once.
and practice fitting them once in the dry, warm driveway, not for the first time on the shoulder in a storm with the hazards on. ask me how i know.
Log in to reply. No account yet? Ask a mod, it takes a day or two.